Get Adobe Flash player

Whitley County Patriots Official Response to the “Reasonable permit” Wind Article

As many of you know, on February 1st, the Post and Mail published a front-page story that was heavily biased towards the proposed industrial wind turbine installation in Whitley County.  It portrayed the three primary benefactors of the project as “second-class citizens” who were being deprived of the use of their land.

Whitley County Patriots is opposed to industrial wind energy due to the incredible about of tax subsidies and abatements that must be poured into it to make wind energy viable.  We took offense to the blatant use of the newspaper’s resources to plaster an OPINION all over the front page, and make it look like NEWS.

This is our official response.  This article was printed on the opinion page of the Post and Mail on February 8th.

Winners and losers…

Whitley County Patriots would like to respond to the article “A reasonable permit” published as the headline story in the Post and Mail on February 1, 2012, in which three Whitley County farmers were given this newspaper’s resources to put forward their point of view supporting the proposed industrial wind turbine project in southern Whitley County.

What’s the difference between Obama giving your tax money to Solyndra and giving your tax money to Wind Capital?  One made solar panels, and one erects wind turbines.  One filed bankruptcy (Solyndra), and one company (NTR PLC., parent of Wind Capital) currently has a stock price of 0.30 Euro.  In America, we call that a “penny stock”.  I don’t know what a Euro penny is called, do you?  In America, this stock would get delisted from both NYSE and NASDAQ.

Have you heard that it is a right-wing agenda that prevents wind turbines from operating at 100%?  Republicans have been accused of killing asthmatics with pollution from coal-fired generators by keeping the wind from blowing 400 feet from ground level.  I guess Mother Nature must be a Republican.

Before government can give money to anyone, it must take money from everyone in the form of taxes.  It really doesn’t grow on trees.  When did it become the job of government to pick winners and losers?  By giving our tax money to greedy corporate farmers, government is making them winners, while making the rest of us losers.  We losers keep on emptying our pockets for the winners.  Mr. Sickafoose says that “the farmers got screwed.”  Who is really getting screwed?

These so-called “wind-farmers” already receive millions of dollars from the USDA as farm subsidies.  Why do we need to give them more money to farm wind?  It seems like they are farming more in tax subsidies than agriculture.

Wind-created electricity is the most expensive power available.  It’s a shame that the REMC can’t buy that high-priced electricity, eliminate the need for coal-fired plants, and triple the electric bills of these “Solyndras of agriculture” without also tripling the bills of us losers.  Are the “winners” going to help with the “green power” electric bills they helped to create?
Aren’t our elected Commissioners and appointed Plan Commission supposed to consider the “quality of life” impact of their decisions for the entire county, not just the special interests?  Is the Plan Commission supposed to pick the winners and losers for Whitley County?  How can they justify creating 150 winners, while creating 33,000 losers? Maybe they need to hear the voices of more potential losers.

Why is wind energy so important?  Has anyone named an economic benefit from wind energy?  Our farming friends claim it to be in the form of lease payment windfalls, tax revenue, and lower tax rates for all.  These are nothing more than the money moving from losers to winners.  Economic benefits are realized when a product is produced at a profit.  There is no economic benefit when government forces consumers to pay inflated prices to the winners.

Let’s talk about the Whitley County budget.  When you look at the 10-year numbers in the Umbaugh report, you will find that the total “windfall” from this project is actually less than 1.5% of the current county budget.  How can we say that Whitley County will collect that revenue when the “facts” that went into the report came directly from Wind Capital?  Even if we assume the numbers are good, just five new $250,000 homes each year in Jefferson Township will have a larger impact on county revenue.  It’s a crying shame that nobody builds those kinds of homes in the middle of an industrial wind installation. It’s also a shame that the falling property values in the area will destroy any hope of lowering the property tax rates for us losers.

Mr. Reiff and Mr. Trier claim that the county is “confiscating 1,500 feet” of their property from “future economic development.”   This is simply a case of a new shoe being on the winners’ feet rather than the losers.  Were this boondoggle project to be allowed to continue, the winners would lose no sleep over the casting of shadows, throwing of ice, and sweeping noise onto the property of the losers to whom they sold a home parcel a few years ago.

Government has been taking control over land and labor for years.  Now, when the winners are at the pointy end of the stick, they cry “foul”.  I haven’t heard of any farmers coming to the aid of the landlord in Ogden Dunes who was fined $40,000 for renting his single-family home to a single family.

In closing, I don’t see any difference between one who says “I’m not too proud of my county”, and one who says “I have never been proud of my country.”
So, winners and losers, what good are 16 miles of new roads that dead end at wind turbines?

Terry Smith
Whitley County Patriots

God Bless America

Find Us On Facebook!

Hot Topics

Random Quote

Government does not solve problems; it subsidizes them. — Ronald Reagan

Today’s Events


Upcoming Elections

  • No dates present